Protestant preaching during the Great War

During the First World War French Protestant preachers became radicalised and advocated French patriotism and supposed superiority opposed to German imperialism deemed responsible for the horrors of war. Thus was theological opposition added to military opposition.

The glory of France renewed by the ideals of the Revolution

  • Sermon imprimé du pasteur aumônier Georges Lauga (1917)
    Printed sermon of pastor chaplain Georges Lauga (1917) © Collection privée
  • Aumôniers et soldats malgaches et tahitiens (1917)
    Malagasy and Tahitian chaplains and soldiers (1917) © DEFAP (Service protestant de mission)
  • Lettre adressée au pasteur Jean Bianquis - poste militaire (1917)
    Letter to pastor Jean Bianquis – military post (1917) © DEFAP (Service protestant de mission)

In their preaching French pastors insisted on pre-war French decadence and on the revival of its humanness since the outbreak of the conflict. Sermons became more radical with the nonchalance of France’s past being forgotten thanks to the heroism of French soldiers. Paradoxically the French Revolution became the main theme for preachers. Pastors were fundamentally republican and saw a direct link between the Revolution and the Third Republic, as both advocated the continuity of the modern values of the Calvinist Reformation.

France as a symbol of humanist and democratic values

  • Monuments aux morts - Faculté de théologie de Montpellier
    War Memorial – School of theology in Montpellier © Collection privée

French pastors conveyed a glorious image of France, in contrast to German history fraught with mistakes and grim mass murders. They promoted great figures such as Hugo, Zola, Gambetta and Jaurès who inspired and promoted the French spirit of freedom and democracy. In August 1914, Pastor Jean Lafon mentioned ‘the great principles of freedom, equality and brotherhood which changed the face of Europe, and have become with time the charter and safeguard of emancipated peoples.’ France was the figurehead concerning ‘Universal Rights’, and became ‘the teacher of other nations, the vigilant sentinel of a civilization forever threatened by recession.’ Still the most powerful weapon of preachers remained the comparison with German imperialism and the abuses of the regime.

The Kaiser and the German elites heading despotic imperialism

  • Guillaume II (1859-1941)
    Wilhelm II (1859-1941) © Wikimedia Commons

French preachers insisted on the crimes committed by the German imperial regime during the war. The Germans were shown alternately as liars, or cruel and domineering individuals; they were also considered as the barbaric people who started the war. However the Kaiser and the middle-class elite who ruled the empire were the most criticized. The preachers condemned German imperialism for ‘reason of state prevailing over the reason of self-consciousness.’ Wilhelm II was called a ‘modern Cesar’, a ‘bloodthirsty prince’, the ‘emperor of murderers.’ The Kaiser had adopted a violent and aggressive attitude to stress the difference with his predecessors and have his name mentioned in history books…The violent conflict, the authoritarian German regime and diplomatic betrayals for which he was deemed responsable fed the accusations of the French preachers.

German intellectuals serving a ‘decadent’ German Kultur

French pastors were deeply convinced that German intellectuals served pan-Germanism and imperialism advocated by Wilhelm II, as seems to be proven by the ‘Appeal to the civilised world’ signed by 93 German intellectuals on 4 October, 1914. They aimed to reduce the noble notion of Auferklärung (Enlightenment) to a military doctrine; had been blinded by their ‘pride’ rooted in their knowledge and science; and thus would not be aware of their theological error.

In the process, French pastors established an opposition between the pre-war German theology thought, to which they gave credit, and the war-time philosophy which would henceforth focus win the worship of the state.

Author: Maguelone Maissin et Noah Wans

Bibliography

  • Documents
    • Comité mémoire de l'Aumônerie protestante aux armées, Histoire de l’aumônerie militaire protestante pendant la Grande Guerre | File
  • Books
    • GAMBAROTTO Laurent, Foi et Patrie, La prédication du protestantisme français pendant la Première Guerre Mondiale, Labor et Fides, Genève, 1996
  • Articles
    • GAMBAROTTO Laurent, "L’opposition radicalisée de deux nations, régimes politiques et visions du monde (français et allemand) dans la prédication de guerre du protestantisme réformé français", Bulletin , Société de l’Histoire du Protestantisme Français, Paris, 2014, Tome 160, p. 35-55

Associated tours

Random notes